The setup: Brother and Sister have come down with the gimmies, making a fuss to get what they want at the supermarket checkout, at the mall, in the parking lot, every which where. Papa keeps giving in, Mama keeps objecting, and it all comes to a head when Grizzly Gramps and Gran show up at the door and the cubs scream "What'd you bring me?" as they're coming up the steps.

The Title Page
So many delicious looking goodies. The toys maybe not so much, although I appreciate THREE squeaky cats that stick out their tongue.
With my kids, every single dinner needs to end with a dessert, and they'll use every line in the book to get it. "Oh, but I ate my vegetables." "Oh, but I always get it." "Oh, but my little brother got one yesterday that was really big and now I need one." They also get it quite often going out to the store. Any trip to the grocery store will often lead with a little side trip to the toy section, and they'll ask us for something. Sometimes I think of it as parenting practice. It's a good opportunity to practice saying no and the kids getting practice hearing no.

This is definitely one of my favorites of all the books. It's a very useful topic to talk about with kids, because there's not a kid alive who doesn't get some form of the gimmies at some point in time.

The Opening Rhyme
Pretty general statement, but hinting that it'll be up to the parents to decide how THEY need to change, not as much the cubs.
How the gimmies happen
Being able to see what that enabling behavior looks like, seeing the cubs go on this meltdown of just wanting more and more and more, not even really being happy with what they have but just moving on to the next thing, and then ultimately having that reckoning moment where Mama and Papa have the conversation (why are the cubs behaving this way? what can we do about it?) is a really realistic type of thing that happens. That's where the plot starts to pivot into a resolution.
I like how they bring in Grizzly Gramps and Gran, who provide context to Papa Bear: hey, this isn't just the cubs being bad and greedy. It's something that happened to you, this is why it happened, and this is how we thought about it. As a parent of young kids, it's easy to get caught up in the moment or have some existential concern about the state of your kids, like, oh, am I just doing everything wrong and that's why they're behaving this way? Being able to get that elder wise knowledge from grandparents or from your own parents is a great addition here.
And the plot ends well in terms of the plan going through, the cubs eliminate their gimmies. Maybe they're not being told no, but ultimately they do recognize that greedy behavior is not good, and they can see that externally being played out through other cubs.
It starts with the parents
When it comes to the moral of the story, it's a lot less about the cubs having greedy behavior and more about the cause of the greedy behavior. The whole intro to the book is about how the parents love the cubs so much, and because they love them so much, oftentimes they'll give them things. Sometimes just giving things can lead to a case of the gimmies. There's also a really interesting point where they talk about how the cubs are constantly exposed to a lot of temptations, on the TV, walking through the store, just wherever they looked. I think this is probably the Berenstain Bears version of commenting on a materialistic culture. More stuff always in somebody's face, and them wanting whatever they see.
Any parent who knows about the gimmies knows that it really starts with them. There's some moment where they're doing something to be nice or just to avoid friction. That's probably most common, giving them something just because you don't want to put up with a fight. I always go back to the example of our kids with night snack. It's something that we initially said yes to probably because we just wanted to be nice, or maybe they had a really bad dinner that night and we just wanted to get a banana in their stomach before they fall asleep. That turns into a habit where the next time they want it because they had it the first time. We already set the precedent and it's just easier to say yes again. Before you know it, it's a month straight of night snacks, you realize they really shouldn't be having this food right before bed, and when you say no, all of a sudden you get the big fuss. It's very much a book for the parents to realize that, as much as for the kids to see how ugly greedy behavior looks from the other side of it.
The secondary lesson is something Papa brings up in his talk with the cubs that doesn't really seem to land with them too well. He says you can't ever be happy when you have the gimmies because you always want more, more, more. The thing that you just got doesn't provide you any happiness because you're already thinking about the next thing that you want. Number one, this is just outright true, and it's a lesson that we'll take from this book and teach to our kids all of the time. Obviously that's not a lesson a kid hears once and then is forever like, oh, I don't need anything ever. But it's a good reminder. Actual joy doesn't come from the wanting, it comes from the satisfaction of what you have. And as future bears might call it, counting your blessings.
The one area worth further discussion is the Grizzly Gramps and Gran plan, where to combat the gimmies the cubs pick out one thing they want before they go to the store. If they don't get the gimmies, they keep it. If they get the gimmies, they go home empty handed. From one perspective, this is a great way to eliminate those moments, because the cubs know in the back of their mind that if they fuss, they lose the thing.
But what it's not effective for is getting them used to hearing the word no. They're still allowed to get something each time they go. Ultimately that's the end lesson the cubs should learn, that you can be told no and it's okay. You don't get everything that you want. I understand why they didn't initially go for that. It's almost a step-by-step program here: first step, remove these bad episodes of the galloping greedy gimmies. Maybe if the book were to continue a little longer, it would be, hey, not every time we go to the store will you get something, and if you complain about that, you'll never get something.
Those black eyes
Illustrations front to back, absolutely amazing. Easily five out of five. My absolute favorite facial expressions in these books (I would like to do a blog post on this at some point, a deep dive of the scenarios where it happens) are the special type of eyes they draw on the bears where they completely remove the whites from their eyes. Just black eyes. Sometimes they'll do it when the image is really zoomed out far away, but here we get it zoomed in.
When Papa goes against Mama's wishes and hands over the candy with his "you're only young once," those eyes are showing a little bit of guilt that he's overriding Mama Bear, but also a bit of loving dadhood, somewhat satisfied that he's making them happy.
Then on the very next page we get the same eye treatment from Mama Bear, except in this case it's showing total dissatisfaction with Papa. It's not a good example of unified joint parenting. She's mad that he went against what she said, when she's probably aware that there is a bad case of the gimmies happening and this is only making it worse.

These eyes from Papa Bear in one illustration and from Mama say 10,000 words and I have been both of them before.
It highlights what makes the illustrations of these books so great. You can read the text and get a really great plot, but when you combine it with illustrations that show this much emotion on the bears' faces, you end up getting double the amount of context you would just by reading the words. They'll break out these eyes in future books as well, and every single time I see it, I look at it and I smile.
Of course we also get a lot of really great meltdown scenes, maybe the best of which is where Sister was jumping up and down so hard that she fell over backward and started kicking her feet in the air. It's such an extreme meltdown in the parking lot that it's the example page I would think of when I'm telling them, hey, this is really embarrassing. Look at these cubs. This is ridiculous.

The ultimate meltdown, observed by seemingly all of Bear Country.
Every page has multiple images on it. We get Papa Bear going from enabling to the madness of them all, and Mama giving a Kermit I-told-you-so type of look, and she even sips her tea while she does it. Maybe that's what the Kermit meme was based off of, Mama Bear.
The cubs go through a wide range of emotion too, really happy when they're getting something, complaining, then buying into the Gramps and Gran plan, and at the end this satisfied, look-at-us pride. They got their crayons and their dinosaur book, and then comes their look of exasperation when another cub has the gimmies behind them in the checkout line. As a parent that's super funny, because that was literally them the last time they went to the store. It shows the plan kind of worked. They have that realization now.

The nameless cub having a meltdown at the end. I promise you I will find out who this bear is.
Your parenting is on display
One thing I really enjoy about this book is the experience of third parties observing bad behavior from children, and the parents' reaction to it. It's somewhere I've definitely been before. You're in a grocery store, your kids are acting poorly, other people are around, maybe not directly watching, but at least passive observers. Is that the time where you really want to scream at them? Is that the time where you just let it happen and not say anything? You're almost on display. Your parenting is on display. We get a lot of that through this book, and it's never mentioned outright in any of the text that these other bears were looking on with disgust. It's all done through the illustrations. When you're the parent, you see those and you're like, yes, I've been in that situation.
The first one is the parking lot gimmies, where there's just some random bear selling squeaky cats. Which, by the way, is kind of a weird thing. Maybe this was different in the eighties, but I think it would be weird for some random guy to be selling toys in the parking lot of a grocery store. The bear selling the toys gives Papa this I'm-sorry look, but also a still-take-your-money-for-the-toy look, and there are bears in the background putting groceries in their cars looking shocked by the behavior. You can only imagine Mama Bear's reaction if she knew these other adults were looking on in horror. We get a few more great examples too: Grizzly Gramps and Gran looking stunned as Papa's yelling at the kids to go upstairs, like, oh, well, what did we walk in on? And the flashback with young Papa Bear throwing a meltdown while Rufe Grizzly of Rufe Grizzly's General Store looks on with disappointment.

Papa Bear looking awfully like Sister Bear in the previous image. Also Molasses apples, not caramel apples? I might need to try that.
That becomes really beneficial when talking with the kids about the gimmies: hey, look at how these bears look here. Would you be embarrassed having to watch that? It gives kids a chance to reflect a little on, ooh, that actually isn't a great look. That's not to say kids are aware of it in the moment. Obviously the passions of the galloping greedy gimmies will sometimes take over.
Side note: galloping greedy gimmies, amazing phrase. They're not just calling it being greedy, it's the gimmies, or the galloping greedy gimmies, and it adds a flavor to the book that makes it fun. It is now a word we use constantly throughout our household whenever we see a good case of it. I'm sure my kids immediately think back to Brother and Sister on their backs, kicking their legs, screaming and crying in the parking lot, and in an ideal world come to the realization that they should stop. It's not always the case.
The Berenstain Bears Get the Gimmies by Stan and Jan Berenstain (1988). A picture book for ages 3 to 8, it runs about 10½ minutes aloud. It earns 5/5 and a Dad's Pick. But the book would be better served if there was a moment where the cubs heard the word no and ultimately were okay with it. That's the one spot of this book that is missing.


